Christoph Wappler
Comparative Analysis of Department Stores and Shopping Centers in Germany and
Spain
ISBN-10: 3-8324-9815-X
ISBN-13: 978-3-8324-9815-3
Druck Diplomica® GmbH, Hamburg, 2006
Zugl. Otto-von-Guericke-Universität Magdeburg, Magdeburg, Deutschland, MA-Thesis /
Master, 2006
Dieses Werk ist urheberrechtlich geschützt. Die dadurch begründeten Rechte,
insbesondere die der Übersetzung, des Nachdrucks, des Vortrags, der Entnahme von
Abbildungen und Tabellen, der Funksendung, der Mikroverfilmung oder der
Vervielfältigung auf anderen Wegen und der Speicherung in Datenverarbeitungsanlagen,
bleiben, auch bei nur auszugsweiser Verwertung, vorbehalten. Eine Vervielfältigung
dieses Werkes oder von Teilen dieses Werkes ist auch im Einzelfall nur in den Grenzen
der gesetzlichen Bestimmungen des Urheberrechtsgesetzes der Bundesrepublik
Deutschland in der jeweils geltenden Fassung zulässig. Sie ist grundsätzlich
vergütungspflichtig. Zuwiderhandlungen unterliegen den Strafbestimmungen des
Urheberrechtes.
Die Wiedergabe von Gebrauchsnamen, Handelsnamen, Warenbezeichnungen usw. in
diesem Werk berechtigt auch ohne besondere Kennzeichnung nicht zu der Annahme,
dass solche Namen im Sinne der Warenzeichen- und Markenschutz-Gesetzgebung als frei
zu betrachten wären und daher von jedermann benutzt werden dürften.
Die Informationen in diesem Werk wurden mit Sorgfalt erarbeitet. Dennoch können
Fehler nicht vollständig ausgeschlossen werden, und die Diplomarbeiten Agentur, die
Autoren oder Übersetzer übernehmen keine juristische Verantwortung oder irgendeine
Haftung für evtl. verbliebene fehlerhafte Angaben und deren Folgen.
© Diplomica GmbH
http://www.diplom.de, Hamburg 2006
Printed in Germany
III
Table of Contents
Page
List of Figures ...VI
List of Tables ...VII
List of Abbreviations ... VIII
1 Introduction ... 1
1.1 Overview... 1
1.2 Comparing Department Stores and Shopping Centers ... 3
2 Data
Collection... 6
2.1 Countries ... 6
2.1.1 Germany... 6
2.1.2 Spain... 8
2.2 Large-Scale
Retailing... 11
2.2.1 Department Stores... 12
2.2.2 Shopping Centers ... 15
3 Case
Studies ... 20
3.1 Karstadt Warenhaus/Karstadt Quelle... 20
3.1.1 History... 20
3.1.2 Karstadt's Crisis... 22
3.1.3 Facts and Figures ... 23
3.1.4 Forecast ... 24
3.2 El Corte Inglés ... 27
3.2.1 History... 27
3.2.2 Facts and Figures ... 28
Table of Contents
IV
3.2.3 Forecast ... 29
3.3 ECE
Projektmanagement ... 30
3.3.1 History... 30
3.3.2 Facts and Figures ... 32
3.3.3 Forecast ... 33
3.4 Sonae Sierra/Sonae SGPS... 34
3.5 Excursus: Galeria Kaufhof/Metro Group... 34
3.6 Excursus:
ALDI ... 35
4 Strategic
Analysis ... 38
4.1 External Environment Analysis ... 39
4.1.1 Macro Environment Forces... 41
4.1.1.1 Political
Factors ... 41
4.1.1.2 Economic
Factors... 42
4.1.1.3 Socio-cultural
Factors ... 43
4.1.1.4 Technological
Factors... 44
4.1.2 Micro Environment Forces ... 44
4.1.2.1 Buyers ... 45
4.1.2.2 Substitutes ... 47
4.1.2.3 Suppliers ... 47
4.1.2.4 Potential
Entrants ... 48
4.1.2.5 Rivalry among Existing Firms ... 48
4.2 Internal Environment Analysis ... 49
4.3 Strategy
Formulation ... 50
4.4 Successful
Business
Models ... 53
Table of Contents
V
5 Benchmarking... 55
5.1 Profiles ... 56
5.1.1 Germany vs. Spain ... 56
5.1.2 Department Stores vs. Shopping Centers... 57
5.1.3 Karstadt vs. El Corte Inglés ... 59
5.2 Implications... 61
6 Conclusion... 64
6.1 Further
Research ... 66
Annex 1: Six-year Summary of Karstadt... 67
Annex 2: Comparison of Germany and Spain ... 68
Annex 3: Comparison of the EU and the USA ... 69
Annex 4: Index Scores and Ranks for Countries and Regions from the IBM Set ... 70
Annex 5: Computations for the Profiles... 71
Bibliography... 76
VI
List of Figures
Figure 1: Overview of the Thesis...2
Figure 2: Department Store vs. Shopping Center vs. Central Business District...5
Figure 3: Business Unit Strategic-Planning Process...38
Figure 4: Opportunity Matrix...40
Figure 5: Threat Matrix...40
Figure 6: Five Competitive Forces...45
Figure 7: Generic Strategies: Karstadt Stuck in the Middle ...61
VII
List of Tables
Table 1: Case Studies...20
Table 2: Checklist for Performing Strength and Weakness Analysis...50
Table 3: Generic Strategies ...51
Table 4: Characteristics of Successful Business Models ...54
Table 5: Profile of the Macro Economic Forces in Germany and Spain ...57
Table 6: Profile of the Internal Environment Analysis of Karstadt and El Corte Inglés 60
VIII
List of Abbreviations
CEO
Chief executive officer
EBIT
Earnings before interests and taxes
EBITDA
Earnings before interests, taxes, depreciation and amortization
ECE
ECE Projektmanagement GmbH & Co. KG
ed.
Edition
et al.
Et alii (and others)
ETA
Euskadi Ta Askataska (Basque Homeland and Freedom)
EU
European
Union
EU-15
The 15 initial countries of the European Union
EU-25
All 25 current European Union member countries
FRG
Federal Republic of Germany
GDP
Gross Domestic Product
GDR
German
Democratic
Republic
GLA
Gross leasable area
H&M
Hennes and Mauritz
ICSC
International Council of Shopping Centers
IVA
Impuesto sobre el valor anadido (value added tax in Spain)
loc. cit.
Loco citato (at the place already cited)
n/a
Not
available
NATO
North Atlantic Treaty Organisation
OECD
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
PEST
Political, economic, socio-cultural and technological
PSOE
Partido Socialista Obrero Español (Spanish Socialist Workers' Party)
List of Abbreviations
IX
SWOT
Strength, weaknesses, opportunities and threats
USt
Umsatzsteuer (value added tax in Germany)
UN
United
Nations
VAT
Value added tax
vs.
Versus
1
1
Introduction
Why are traditional German department stores close to bankruptcy in a time when so
many new shopping centers with a similar offering of goods are being built? Is this
phenomenon just a problem of German companies or do other countries have the same
situation? For comparison, the situations in different countries, Germany and Spain are
picked.
Most of the literature in the field of retail management is written about US American
companies. Thus, this thesis cannot totally ignore it. E-commerce, despite its growing
importance, is not part of this comparison, as both retail formats are faced with the same
opportunities and threats by it.
The starting point of this thesis is the difficult situation Karstadt was facing in the last
two years and the story about the successful department store concept of El Corte Inglés
in Spain; hence these two companies play a major role throughout this thesis.
1.1
Overview
The introduction provides the reader with an overview of the thesis. Furthermore, the
question is addressed, if department stores and shopping centers can be compared.
The main body of this thesis consists of three parts, which are structured after the same
pattern: country level, industry level and company level. First, data is collected for a
later analysis. Chapter 2 gathers all relevant information about Germany and Spain and
then narrows down to the history of department stores and shopping centers. The
company data is shown in its own chapter 3, as a major part of this thesis should be the
company comparison of Karstadt and El Corte Inglés. The market leaders in the
respective markets are shown in case studies and complemented by data of the two
companies that emphasizes the final analysis and conclusion.
Introduction
2
Figure 1: Overview of the Thesis
D
ATA
C
OLLECTION
Countries and Industries
Company Case Studies
I
NTRODUCTION
T
HEORETICAL
B
ACKGROUND
Strategic Analysis
C
OMPARATIVE
A
NALYSIS
Benchmarking
C
ONCLUSION
C
HAPTER
1
C
HAPTER
2
C
HAPTER
3
C
HAPTER
5
C
HAPTER
4
C
HAPTER
6
Introduction
3
The theoretical background of company analysis is given in chapter 4. Again, the first
part about the macro environment concentrates on the country level. Then, the micro
environment forces comparing the attractiveness of industries are explained. The last
part contains the fundamentals of the internal environment analysis, which reflects the
company level.
In chapter 5, the findings are used to construct profiles, point out differences between
the different countries, industries and companies, and to find ideas for improving the
existing management strategies of the given companies.
The conclusion not only provides a summary of the thesis, it also gives a forecast and
identifies sources and possibilities for further research.
1.2
Comparing Department Stores and Shopping Centers
The typical comparison made in literature as well as in politics, is the comparison of
shopping centers and central business districts. While central business districts were the
dominant form in the past, the importance of shopping centers has grown within the last
decades. Stores, sited in central business districts for many decades, went bankrupt,
after a new shopping center in the neighborhood opened its doors.
1
European central
business districts are not ready for this competition from well-managed shopping
centers. They need the help of the government to keep them from dying, because if the
right combination of specialty stores exists in a shopping center, it can replace a
traditional department store
2
or central business district.
1
See Gipp (2005), p. 1.
2
See ECE Projektmanagement GmbH & Co. KG (2006a).
Introduction
4
There are different opinions about whether or not shopping centers are retailers.
3
From a
pragmatic point of view, a shopping center can be considered as large-scale retailer.
4
The shopping center management companies do not engage in the selling of
merchandise, but rent the location to shops. As the rent consists of a fixed payment and
a variable payment, based on the shops income, the management of shopping centers is
interested in successful tenants and shows many parallels to department store
management.
5
How do department stores fit into this comparison? Comparing the separate departments
of these large-scale retailers with their competitors, the answer to this question is easier
to find. A typical department has its competitors in the next shopping street, in a central
business district or in a shopping center.
6
Not just other department stores, but also the
combination of stores existing in shopping centers or central business districts can
replace a whole department store.
The concept of benchmarking allows not only comparisons within an industry, but
encourages a company to learn from other sectors.
7
Hence, taking shopping centers as a
benchmark might help the department store industry to overcome weaknesses, and
profit from new concepts and vice versa.
Normally, department stores are located in premium locations in central business
districts, shopping streets of suburbs or in shopping centers. Shopping centers can be
found in central business districts, shopping streets of suburbs and especially in the
USA in Greenfield sites. As illustrated in figure 2, even the intersection of all three
types is prevalent: a department store in a downtown shopping center.
Within the scope of this study, department stores and shopping centers will be
compared. Department stores in Europe, like Karstadt and El Corte Inglés, are normally
3
See Nieschlag/Kuhn (1980), p. 200.
4
See Marzen (1985), p. 178.
5
See ECE Projektmanagement GmbH & Co. KG (2006c).
6
See Karstadt Warenhaus GmbH (2005).
7
See Macharzina (2003), p. 243.
Introduction
5
not located in shopping centers. They are present in central business district and other
premium locations like the main shopping street of a suburb, since they were built many
years before shopping centers were invented.
8
Figure 2: Department Store vs. Shopping Center vs. Central Business District
In the next chapter, data about the two countries and the history of department stores
and shopping centers is presented to provide a more sophisticated understanding of the
leading question of this thesis.
Why are traditional German department stores close to bankruptcy in a time when so
many new shopping centers with a similar offering of goods are being built? Is this
phenomenon just a problem of German companies or do other countries have the
same situation?
8
See Karstadt Warenhaus GmbH (2005).
6
2
Data Collection
2.1
Countries
In order to later compare Germany and Spain; this chapter collects information about
these member countries of the EU. The political, economic, socio-cultural and
technological information is needed for an analysis of the macro environment forces in
chapter 5.1.1. The concept is explained in chapter 4.1.1.
A summary of the country data is listed in annex 2 and 3.
2.1.1
Germany
Germany is a key member of the political and defense organizations of the European
Union (EU). Germany triggered two World Wars and was occupied by the Allied
powers of the USA, UK, France and the Soviet Union after the end of World War II. In
1949, the western Federal Republic of Germany (FRG) and the eastern German
Democratic Republic (GDR) were formed. The FRG was democratic and become part
of the Western world's economic and security organizations. The Communist GDR was
in Soviet-led Warsaw Pact. After the decline of the USSR and the end of the Cold War
in 1990, Germany had its re-unification and since then, has tried to bring the former
Eastern Germany's productivity and wages up to Western standards.
9
The integration of the Eastern German into Western German economy is a long-term
process, costing year to year, around 70 billion euros. The aging population and the high
unemployment have put strong pressure on the social security system, where outlays
already exceed the contributions from workers. Because wages are often set on a
national basis and the strict labor laws, unemployment is one of Germany's main
problems in these years. Opportunities for Germany are corporate restructurings and the
growing capital markets in the EU.
10
9
See Central Intelligence Agency (2006b).
10
See loc. cit.
Data Collection
7
Germany is not only the nation in Europe with the most neighbor countries, but it also
has the leading economy and the highest population within the EU.
11
But the fifth
largest economy in the world is the slowest growing in the EU.
12
Even if German is the
most widely spoken language in the EU, the official language of the EU is English.
In Germany, unemployment has become a chronic problem in the last few years. After
adjusting the figures for seasonal effects, 11.3% of the civilian labor force is currently
unemployed. While in Western Germany 9.6% of the labor force is unemployed,
Eastern Germany has to fight unemployment of 18%. The highest monthly percentage
within the last couple of years with seasonally adjusted figures, was 12.1% (12.7%
without adjustment), which occurred in March 2005.
13
The value added tax (VAT) Umsatzsteuer (USt) in German is 16%. On 01 January
2007, the VAT will be increased by 3%.
14
The German Council of Economic Experts
advised the German government against taking this step.
15
As an effect of the increase,
the growth rate of the economy will be 1% less and some hundred thousand jobs will be
wiped out.
16
Other job killers are the regulations and laws in Germany, which influence
nearly all parts of life. Middle class entrepreneurs especially suffer under the torrent of
bureaucratic obstacles.
17
The German market shows a polarization towards discount and premium products.
Department stores offering middle class products are the losers of this trend.
18
11
See Kohl (1999), p. 53.
12
See Central Intelligence Agency (2006b).
13
See Bundesagentur für Arbeit (2006), p. 40.
14
See Axel Springer AG (2005b).
15
See Axel Springer AG (2005c).
16
See Axel Springer AG (2005b).
17
See Schmidt (1999), p. 25.
18
See ECE Projektmanagement GmbH & Co. KG (2006c).
Data Collection
8
Germany is a technologically advanced country.
19
The expenditure for research and
development in Germany represented 2.5% of GDP on an EU wide high level, but still
less than from countries like the USA (2.8%) or Japan (3.1%).
20
The political risk in Germany is low, showing a stable environment. In 2002, Germany
had 88 from 100 points (82 in 1998) in the International Country Risk Guide from the
PRS Group. For the situation on law and order, Germany gets 5 out of 6 points. This
stands for low risk. The Global Competitiveness Report from the World Economic
Forum ranks Germany as number 14 out of 80 tested countries. The Global
Competitiveness Report measures the capacity of an economy to achieve sustained
economic growth over a medium-term.
21
2.1.2
Spain
The Spanish civil war from 1936 to 1939 ended with the dictatorship of General
Francisco Franco. Not only were many human lives lost, but also the destruction of a
large part of the production facilities was a consequence of the war. Thus, Spain could
not gain economic benefit from staying neutral in World War II, like other countries
did. Until 1959, the politics of Franco incorporated the ability to stay independent from
imports by subsidizing the industry. Because it was not included in the Marshall Plan,
Spain experienced an era of stagnation.
22
Until 1957, many sectors were controlled by the state, including prices on agricultural
products, allocation of resources and wages. The consequences were wrong investment,
bureaucratic delaying, quality problems of the industry, insufficient quotas, corruption,
a growing black market and an increase in the difference in the standards of living of the
rich and the poor.
19
See Central Intelligence Agency (2006b).
20
See Eurostat (2005), p. 2.
21
See Enterprise Estonia (2006).
22
See Nohlen/Hildenbrand (2005), p. 21.
Data Collection
9
When Spain opened up for foreign countries, the Economic Miracle began. The
economic growth rates reached nine per cent per year, supported by a sky rocketing
tourism industry.
23
In 1975, the dictatorship ended with the death of the 82-year-old
Franco, and Juan Carlos I became king of Spain. The political system in Spain is a
parliamentary monarchy.
Even though voices for the independence of Catalonia get louder
24
, the biggest problem
in internal politics in Spain is the conflict with the Basque "Euskadi Ta Askatasuna"
25
(ETA).
26
The group became radical under the Franco regime in the 1960s, because any
kind of independence for the Basques was repressed. Numerous ceasefires were broken
by the ETA and resulted in bomb attacks, killings and abduction of industrialists.
27
On
the 11 March 2004, the days before the elections of the "Cortes Generales"
28
, bomb
attacks in four trains in Madrid killed 191 people. The former prime minister of Spain
José María Aznar accounted the ETA guilty for the killings. Large demonstrations
against the misinformation politics of the Aznar started, when the Al-Qaeda was held
responsible.
29
The outsider "Partido Socialista Obrero Español"
30
(PSOE) with José Luis Rodríguez
Zapatero won the elections with a small majority. During the government of Aznar,
Spain isolated itself in Europe with US oriented politics, while the cabinet around
Zapatero is more oriented towards the EU.
31
23
See loc. cit., p. 22.
24
See Deutschlandradio (2006).
25
Translated: Basque Homeland and Freedom.
26
See Nohlen/Hildenbrand (2005), p. 338.
27
See loc. cit., pp. 273-275.
28
Los Cortes Generales are the Spanish parliament.
29
See 3sat (2004).
30
Translated: Spanish Socialist Workers' Party.
31
See Nohlen/Hildenbrand (2005), pp. 16-17.
Data Collection
10
Spain is one of the ten largest economies in the world, the second largest country, by
size, in the EU-15 after France and the driest country in the EU.
32
Very strong sectors
are the construction, real estate and tourisms industries as well as private consumption.
Just the construction sector contributes 17.7% to the GDP.
33
Spain (1.1% of GDP) is far
behind the EU-25 average (1.9%) on research and development expenditures.
34
With the inclusion in the EU in 1986, Spain experienced five years of intensive growth
above EU average. The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita of Spain started with
only 70.4% of EU average in 1985 and increased to 79.3% in 1991 (75% of the German
GDP). Especially, the high domestic demand helped the economy. After some years of
recession, Spain together with Ireland showed again the highest growth rates in the EU
in the second half of the 1990s.
35
The unemployment in Spain was cut in half from 1995 (22.9%) to 2002 (11.3%).
36
The
VAT in Spain is called impuesto sobre el valor anadido (IVA) and amounts to 16%.
37
The inflation has been on a high level for decades. From 1990 to 1995 the average
inflation was 5.4%, while from 1991 to today the inflation averaged out less than
3.0%.
38
Spain used to be the biggest beneficiary of EU payments. But from 2007 these
payments will constantly be decreased as Spain's GDP per capita will be above the
critical 90% line of the now bigger EU-25.
39
In Spain, four languages are official. While the Spanish constitution says in article 3
that Castilian (Spanish) has to be known by everyone and everybody has the right to use
it
40
, three regions are bilingual and speak Catalan, Basque or Galician as well. Around
32
See loc. cit., pp. 21, 108.
33
See Burgdorff et al. (2004), p. 513.
34
See Eurostat (2005), p. 2.
35
See Nohlen/Hildenbrand (2005), pp. 23-27.
36
See loc. cit., p. 27.
37
See Spanieninfo Agrupacion (2006).
38
See Wirtschaftskammers Österreichs (2006), p.1.
39
See Burgdorff et al. (2004), p. 513.
40
See Congreso de los Diputados (2002).
Data Collection
11
425 million people in the world speak Spanish, what make Spanish the fourth most
widely spoken language in the world.
41
But behind the term Spain, not only four languages are hidden. The country
incorporates four different cultures and four different nations
42
, minorities like the
Gitanos the Spanish gypsies not included.
Trademarks and quality are very important to Spanish consumers.
43
2.2
Large-Scale Retailing
Technology and globalization are reshaping the world with an accelerating rate of
change. Companies can change or they will disappear from the market.
44
Thus, they
need to find new competitive advantages. Some department store companies faced these
challenges successfully for more than 100 years and constantly reinvented its business.
Others were not able to prosper and lost their competitive advantage in the last years.
Thus, these companies went bankrupt.
To learn how department stores and shopping centers grew over time to the big large-
scale retailers they are now, this chapter gives an overview of their history.
41
See Pearson Education (2006).
42
See Bernecker/Oehrlein (1991), p. 387.
43
See Müller (2005), p. 3.
44
See Kotler (1999), p. 3.
Data Collection
12
2.2.1
Department Stores
Department Stores are large retail stores, which are arranged in sometimes more than
100 different departments and sell a wide variety of merchandise, making it available in
one place. Generally, the two major categories sold are apparel and home furnishings.
Department stores offer various services, like fashion shows, home delivery and credit
service, usually in the form of charge accounts. Within department stores
some specialized services or goods are offered by independent companies. They run
their own departments under the name of the department store. Services like
photographic supplies, shoe repair, beauty salons or millinery are often outsourced.
45
In the 1860s, the Bon Marché in Paris became the first department store. This former
dry-goods store was founded in 1838 as a small retail store. A wide assortment of items
was offered at a low and clearly marked price.
46
Most of the first department stores
were outgrowth of dry-goods stores, but also some general stores were the basis for this
new retail format. In 1885, the first store not converted into but directly operated as a
department store was Printemps, which was sited in Paris as well.
47
In the USA, Wanamaker in Philadelphia, Marshall Field in Chicago, Macy & Company
in New York and Jordan Marsh Company in Boston were transformed from dry-goods
stores into department stores in the 1860s and 70s.
This development was encouraged
by the concentration of the American population in urban centers and the growth of a
middle class. Also the introduction of mass manufacturing, new logistic methods as
well as innovations like the telephone, billing machines and the electric light were
needed for this new concept.
48
But not only had the fixed prices characterized this new retail format, merchandise
could be returned and the price was reimbursed or the good exchanged. Another
45
See Microsoft Encarta (2006), Department store.
46
See loc. cit., Bon Marché.
47
See loc. cit., Department store.
48
See loc. cit.
Ende der Leseprobe aus 96 Seiten
- nach oben
Details
- Arbeit zitieren
- , 2006, Comparative Analysis of Department Stores and Shopping Centers in Germany and Spain, Hamburg, Bedey Media GmbH, https://www.diplom.de/document/224932
Ähnliche Arbeiten
Deutschlands größter Sharing Community
Jetzt Zusammenfassungen, Skripte und Klausuren kostenlos downloaden!
Uniturm.de
Ihre Vorteile als Autor
Geld verdienen Für jedes verkaufte Exemplar erhalten Sie Autorenhonorar - bis zu 40%.Kostenlose Buchveröffentlichung
Als eBook-Studie im Original und / oder auf Wunsch zusätzlich als hochwertiges Fachbuch in unserem renommierten Buchverlag.
Renommee als Fachbuchautor
Präsentieren Sie sich als Fachfrau oder Fachmann in Ihrem Fachgebiet und machen Sie sich bekannt.
Persönliche Betreuung
Unser Lektorat wird Sie persönlich betreuen und ist auch telefonisch unter 040-655992-14 erreichbar.
Weltweit im Buchhandel
Ihr Buch ist weltweit im Buchhandel und Online-Buchhandel wie z.B. amazon erhältlich.
Jetzt Autor werden!
Kommentare